How the Nuns of New York Tamed the Gangs of New York

The cast during the curtain call for the Origin Theatre Company’s staging of How the Nuns of New York Tamed the Gangs of New York at the Sheen Center on June 3. (Photo courtesy of the author)

By Mary Pat Kelly, Contributor
August / September 2017

I was able to sniff back tears during most of the moving presentation of the 200 years history of the Sisters of Charity, entitled How the Nuns of New York Tamed the Gangs of New York, at the Sheen Centre on June 3, but I couldn’t stop myself from sobbing when a group of children dressed in 19th century costumes sang “Where is Love” from the movie Oliver. They represented some of the thousands of orphans saved by the sisters from the city’s mean and dangerous streets. Their parents, who had, against all the odds, saved them from Ireland’s Great Hunger, had perished and they too would have died if not for the women whose service was being celebrated in song, dance, and story.

How much we Irish Americans owe to the nuns, I thought, and felt grateful to Turlogh McConnell who worked with the sisters to commemorate their bicentennial (1817 – 2017) in this theatrical presentation, which was directed by George Heslin, founder of the Origin Theatre Company, and narrated by Orlagh Cassidy and Ciaran Byrne.

Saint Elizabeth Ann Seton, founder of the Sisters of Charity.

The piece dramatizes the early days of the sisters. Their founder, Elizabeth Seton, a widow with five children who converted from her prominent family’s Episcopalian faith to Catholicism after her husband died, started the first American congregation of religious women and sent three sisters to open an orphanage in New York in 1817.

How the Nuns of New York Tamed the Gangs of New York, “explores through words, music, and dance the impact of the work of the sisters that grew out of the original 19th century work of healing, teaching, and housing Ireland’s Great Hunger refugees,” McConnell said.

“These remarkable women hold a distinguished place in our city’s history and they will continue to play a critical role, now and in the years to come.”

Two Academy Award winners, director Martin Scorsese and writer John Patrick Shanley, attributed their pursuit of the arts to the inspiration of their Sister of Charity teachers.

St. Patrick’s Old Cathedral School, c. 1978. (Photo: Museum of the City of New York)

Scorsese attended St. Patrick’s Old Cathedral School on New York’s Lower East Side, which was built as an orphanage and convent by the Sisters of Charity in 1826 remained in their care until 2010 when it closed due to low enrolment.

“Prior to that, I had no religious training,” Scorsese said in a 2013 interview with National Endowment for the Humanities president Jim Leach. He also recalled equating the vibrant ceremony and beauty of the church with the glamor of the cinema: “I found some comfort in the old cathedral of St. Patrick’s, and, of course, some comfort in the movie theater.” (The building was sold by the Archdiocese of New York in 2015 and now contains condominiums.)

John Patrick Shanley was educated by the sisters in the Bronx, and based his 2005 Pulitzer Prize-winning play Doubt on his experiences with them and the Christian Brothers. The play is dedicated to Sister Peggy McEntee, Shanley’s Sister of Charity first grade teacher.

“This play is dedicated to the many orders of Catholic nuns who devoted their lives to serving others in hospitals, schools and retirement homes,” he wrote in the playbill. “Though they have been much maligned and ridiculed, who among us has been so generous?”


The Sheen Center plans to stage the performance again in February 2018. Details to come.

2 Responses to “How the Nuns of New York Tamed the Gangs of New York”

  1. Marie says:

    The founder of the Sisters of Charity was Saint Elizabeth Anne Seton,
    is that correct, thus they have no relation to the “Daughters of Charity”
    founded by Ste. Louise and St. Vincent de Paul in Paris in the 1600’s.
    I forget the exact year however the date was the 29th of November, in
    the church of St. Nicolas de Chardonnay.
    Reply needed, thank you.

    • Kathy says:

      At some point, Mother Seton’s sisters in Baltimore formally affiliated with the Daughters of Charity in France. One of the results was a change of habit to that of the French Daughters. Other foundations of Mother Seton, including the Sisters in New York chose not to formally affiliate with the Daughters. However, all congregations of the Seton Sisters of Charity see themselves as part of the wider family of St. Vincent de Paul.

Leave a Reply


More Articles

Queens Irish Center August 3, 2021 Photo: James Higgins © 2021
New York Irish Center Proudly Honors Council Member Danny Dromm

The New York Irish Center on Tuesday, August 3, proudly celebrated the remarkable career of community advocate and...


History Loves a Parade
260 Years of the New York
St. Patrick’s Day Parade

Wednesday, March 17, 2021 4:00 pm EST, 8:00 pm Ireland The New York Irish Center Presents: History Loves A...


Irish American
Heritage Month 2021

A Proclamation on Irish-American Heritage Month, 2021 On Monday March 1, 2021 President Joe Biden proclaimed March...



By Margy Kinmonth Filmmaker Margy Kinmonth writes about making To The Western World, a film inspired by the...